Skip to main content

AppArmor vs SELinux vs Grsecurity

AppArmor learns the behaviors of applications through established access controls (for monitoring and reporting) and enforces application security policies.
Security-Enhanced Linux (SELinux) uses rule-based policy enforcement to restrict the functionality of users and services.
Grsecurity uses Linux Security Modules to enhance security of the Linux kernel.

Features AppArmor SELinux Grsecurity
Allow/Deny Policy Yes Yes Yes
Hierarchical Domains Yes Yes Yes
Object Types Yes Yes Yes
Data Types No No No
Account Management No Yes Yes
Service Management No Yes Yes
Network Management No* Yes Yes
Access Control Lists Yes Yes Yes
Role-Based Access Control Yes Yes Yes
Security Context No Yes No
Linux Kernel Module Yes Yes Yes
Language No Yes Yes
Unified Configuration Yes No No
Doesn't Prohibit Other Applications & Tools Yes No No
No Installation No No No
Few Dependencies Yes No Yes
Automated Execution Yes Yes Yes
Learning Mode Yes No Yes
Self-Managed (no framework, no user interaction) Yes No No
Self-Healing (restorative, no user interaction) No No No
Application Programming Interface No Yes No
Remote Access Control No No No
Intrusion Detection System Yes Yes Yes
Logging Yes Yes Yes
Report Generation Yes Yes No
Intrusion Prevention System Yes No No
Malware Protection Yes Yes+ Yes+
Updated Signature Scanning & Analysis No No No
Deep Packet Inspection (DPI) No No No

+ Software supports only blacklisting.

Do you have a suggestion about how to improve this blog? Let's talk about it. Contact me at David.Brenner.Jr@Gmail.com or 720-584-5229.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

OpenStack+Ceph as Software-Defined Storage

SDS reduces the costs of the management of growing data stores by decoupling storage management from its hardware to allow for centralized management of cheaper, popular commodity hardware. The example SDS ecosystem uses open source software like OpenStack as a front-end interface on top of Ceph as the resource provider of a RADOS cluster of commodity solid-state drives. OpenStack provides user-friendly wrappers for accessing and modifying underlying Ceph storage. OpenStack comes in the form of distributed microservices with RESTful API's: Block (Cinder), File (Manila), Image (Glance), and Object (Swift). Each microservice can scale-out as a cluster of stand-alone services to accommodate the varying demands of high-growth storage. With OpenStack the underlying Ceph storage can address the block storage needs, file storage needs, image storage needs, and object storage needs of datacenters adopting open source as their new norm in an industry trend for high performace and high a

Network traffic monitoring in Linux with Python

You can investigate suspicious activity in your network traffic by collecting relevant machine data from your endpoint. You can use the machine data to create your own analysis. Before you start your investigation you will need to determine normal activity on your endpoint. Normal activity is the scope of functionality of the software on your endpoint during periods of low activity and high activity. You will need some kind of software that periodically collects specific machine data from your endpoint like my software developed in Python that's available for free download at https://github.com/davidbrennerjr/server-stats-collector Ingest one or more of the following machine data: Application specific logs from /var/log Raw dumps from sniffing at Layers 2-3 Raw dumps from /proc of kernel data structures Raw dumps of kernel routing tables General system-wide error messages from /var/log/syslog Do you

Application behavior monitoring in Linux with Python

You can monitor application behaviors by collecting relevant machine data from your endpoint. You can use the machine data to investigate suspicious activity and create your own analysis. Before you start your investigation you will need to determine normal activity on your endpoint. Normal activity is the scope of functionality of the software on your endpoint during periods of low activity and high activity. You will need some kind of software that periodically collects specific machine data from your endpoint like my software developed in Python that's available for free download at https://github.com/davidbrennerjr/server-stats-collector Ingest one or more of the following machine data from Category #1. Ingest one or more of the following machine data from Category #2. Category #1 General system-wide error messages from /var/log/syslog Auditing logs of application rulesets Auditing logs of security contexts Auditing logs of